Beyond the Bestseller–The Answer to a Book Lover’s Dilemma

My recent purchases

I’m always reading novels, memoirs, or essay collections, sometimes two books at once. Given my love of reading, it seems odd that in recent years I’ve had trouble finding books that I really enjoy.

My tastes have changed. Since 2016, I often have wanted to step back from the real world and put my brain on the rinse cycle for a few hours. Unfortunately for me, some of the books that attract critical acclaim often are challenging to read.

The stories may portray truly awful events (slavery, abuse, war crimes) so vividly that reading them leaves me drained, not recharged. Other stories feature antihero characters who are so unlikable that I don’t want to spend a week with them. Or the author may be experimenting with narrative techniques that are intellectually interesting but not emotionally satisfying.

I want escape, but not just any escape. I’m not looking for syrupy sweet, happily-ever-after novels. Instead, I prefer a believable, involving story, one in which the characters are likable or interesting enough that I can engage emotionally and care about their plight.

Finding good books has gotten harder. Zillions of books are published every year. Amazon has millions of them. The public library has thousands. So what’s the big deal?

I’ve realized that my habit of reading with Kindle (whether purchased books or books checked out from the library) has stunted my reading list. In both cases, the recommendation and search algorithms are pretty rudimentary. Just finished a novel about the Holocaust? The library’s app and Amazon’s will suggest three more Holocaust novels. Wait, noooo!

The problem is compounded by the way book marketing and promotion works. During any given month, only 20-30 books are being touted, and the same ones appear on everyone’s bestseller lists and in numerous articles with titles like, “Best Books of 2018” or “This Summer’s 10 Must-Read Books.” Obviously, there are way more than 30 new books out there!  So how can I find them?

An aha moment. Duh. At bookstores. Where they have actual books. Made of paper. Recently, I visited Magers & Quinn and quickly found several good books by award-winning writers and added more to my “Want to Read” list. The books I chose are considered to be “midlist” (which is publisher-speak for a well-written book that is not a bestseller), so none of them were mentioned in any of the reviews or blogs I consult.

What a relief! The books are out there, but I’ve been looking in the wrong places!

If you’re curious, here are three really enjoyable books I purchased recently–The Pearl That Broke Its Shell by Nadia Hashimi, Day After Night by Anita Diamant, and I Will Send Rain by Rae Meadows.

 

Comments

8 responses to “Beyond the Bestseller–The Answer to a Book Lover’s Dilemma”

  1. bbachel Avatar

    Every time I read one of your posts, I think about just how lucky I am to have you as a friend.

    1. Ellen Shriner Avatar

      Wow, what a nice thing to say! I feel the same way;)

  2. Beth Avatar

    I’ll pass along this NPR recommended title, “The Art of the Wasted Day” …read it aloud to truly experience the author’s dance with words! Set in St. Paul. It transports me and I wonder if you would like it too. Enchanting so far 🙂

    1. Ellen Shriner Avatar

      I bought this book but haven’t had a chance to read it!

  3. Ann Coleman Avatar

    I sincerely hope that bookstores never become totally obsolete. They are already all too rare. I do buy some on Amazon, but nothing is better than browsing a real bookstore!

  4. Susanne Avatar

    You so clearly outlined my reading issues of late, too. I’ve given up reading book reviews and have instead returned to random browsing in libraries. I also haunt 2nd hand bookstores.

    1. Ellen Shriner Avatar

      Glad to hear I’m not the only one! Good suggestion about secondhand bookstores.

      1. Katherine Avatar
        Katherine

        Magers & Quinn sells used books along with the new. (And they buy used books, too!) Great bookstore!

Recent Posts

The Mirror

What a twelve-year-old learns to survive sometimes becomes the skill she uses decades later at a poker table. Lying didn’t come naturally to me. I was twelve when I realized, quite suddenly, that I wouldn’t survive my family’s chaos if I didn’t learn how. I stood in front of the assistant principal, heat climbing up…

Hamburger Soup

A bowl of homemade soup could create a few minutes of comfort in this difficult winter of 2025-2026.

Choosing to Believe

A few weeks ago, I visited Pearl Harbor and the USS Arizona memorial. I wasn’t sure what to expect. My father was in the Navy during WWII at Normandy and later in the Pacific. I wanted to honor his service and the legacy of my parents’ generation who sacrificed and died to preserve our democracy. I…


Get WordSisters by Email